The Best Modern Horror Movies on Prime Video Right Now (November 2026)

Availability last updated November 1, 2026. Streaming libraries change monthly, so this list gets updated regularly.

Not in the mood for horror? The best movies on Prime Video right now →

Prime Video’s horror section is a maze of direct-to-streaming junk, but there’s real gold buried in it if you know where to dig. These are the best modern horror movies on Prime Video right now, all released from 2010 on and pulled straight from my rankings of the best horror movies of the 2020s and the best horror movies of the 2010s. You’ll find favorites like The Witch, Pearl and Saint Maud, plus a handful of deeper cuts worth adding to your watchlist. Every pick is streaming in the U.S. right now, and I’ll keep the list updated as titles come and go.

ANTLERS (2021)

🤢59%Critics🍿67%Audience⭐5.9IMDb

For the latest releases, see my roundup of new horror movies.

A teacher in an opioid-hollowed Oregon town realizes the boy she’s worried about is feeding something in his attic. Addiction, generational trauma, poverty, abandonment. There’s no light at the end of the tunnel, just more tunnel.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

THE WITCH (2015)

🍅91%Critics🍿61%Audience⭐7.0IMDb

Living off the land in Puritanical colonial New England goes horribly awry when Black Phillip seduces the youth of an outcast family with promises of delicious living. An ingenuously crafted, sublimely acted masterpiece.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review · Every Robert Eggers Movie, Ranked

HEEL (2025)

🍅88%Critics🍿76%Audience

A family kidnaps a hard-partying, misanthropic 19-year-old and chains him up in their home, determined not just to punish him but to rehabilitate him into one of their own. Stephen Graham and Andrea Riseborough play father and mother consequence, the latter so pale and whispery she seems like a Victorian ghost. A touch A Clockwork Orange meets The Loved Ones, Jan Komasa’s darkly funny psychological thriller heads to rather unexpected places.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · See where it ranks among the best horror of the 2020s

PEARL (2022)

🍅93%Critics🍿83%Audience⭐7.0IMDb

A farm girl in 1918 auditions for a dance troupe as her escape and murders her way toward it. She thinks she can hide her budding psychopathy behind a Hollywood-worthy performance. The trouble is she’s not all that great an actor.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

SAINT MAUD (2020)

🍅92%Critics🍿67%Audience⭐6.6IMDb

A palliative nurse decides her dying patient’s soul is her personal assignment from God. Maud’s connection isn’t blind faith but direct call and response: God Zooms in for a quick chat and a bit of direction. Devotion is cursed.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

IT FOLLOWS (2014)

🍅95%Critics🍿66%Audience⭐6.8IMDb

A demonic STD will not stop hunting Maika Monroe in this deliriously made, minimalist horror-thriller. David Robert Mitchell’s filmmaking is an intellectual puzzle that only gets more bewildering (and better) upon rewatches.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

MIDSOMMAR (2019)

🍅83%Critics🍿63%Audience⭐7.1IMDb

Ari Aster returns with this sun-drenched nightmare epic about a dysfunctional couple who become entangled with a sunny Swedish murder-cult. Florence Pugh is terrific in the lead role. Florence Pugh is devastating as a grieving woman whose relationship falls apart at a sunlit Swedish festival that gets darker by the day.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · See it in my Top Ten of 2019

THE NIGHT HOUSE (2020)

🍅88%Critics🍿69%Audience⭐6.4IMDb

A widow finds her husband built a mirrored version of their lake house across the water, and learns why. Beth confronts a terrifying, mutually exclusive truth: either ghosts exist, or there’s truly nothing waiting beyond this mortal coil.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

📺 Not on Prime Video yet? Start a free Prime trial and watch any of these tonight.

WRONG TURN (2021)

🍅64%Critics🍿59%Audience⭐5.6IMDb

Hikers on the Appalachian Trail cross a self-governing mountain society that has been up there since before the Civil War. A franchise detour that pivots away from everything the series was built on, and is hugely enjoyable for exactly that reason.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

X (2022)

🍅94%Critics🍿76%Audience⭐6.5IMDb

Ti West sends a crew of amateur adult filmmakers to an elderly couple’s farm in 1979 Texas, where their hosts turn out to have very different appetites. Mia Goth pulls double duty in a grimy, gorgeous tribute to The Texas Chain Saw Massacre that has its own morbid things to say about aging, desire, and being left behind.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video

BLINK TWICE (2024)

🍅74%Critics🍿71%Audience⭐6.5IMDb

A cocktail waitress gets invited to a tech billionaire’s private island for an undisclosed stretch of hard partying where days stop connecting. The only prescient question becomes, “are you having enough fun?”▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT KEVIN (2011)

🍅74%Critics🍿78%Audience⭐7.4IMDb

Tilda Swinton plays a mother reckoning with her son’s horrific act and the years of warning signs that led to it. Lynne Ramsay’s fractured, blood-red drama is psychological horror in its purest form, and Ezra Miller is chilling as Kevin.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video

HEREDITARY (2018)

🍅90%Critics🍿72%Audience⭐7.3IMDb

The death of a controlling matriarch sparks the implosion of a family unit in this horrifying study of grief amidst supernatural angst. Toni Collette was robbed. Heads should roll. Ari Aster’s debut is a grief-soaked nightmare, and Toni Collette’s ferocious performance is one of the great horror turns of all time.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

RED ROOMS (2023)

🍅96%Critics🍿73%Audience⭐7.1IMDb

A model becomes obsessed with the trial of a serial killer whose crimes were streamed on the dark web. Pascal Plante’s Québécois thriller never shows the violence and is all the more disturbing for it, anchored by Juliette Gariépy’s icy, unreadable lead.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video

A CURE FOR WELLNESS (2016)

🤢42%Critics🍿42%Audience⭐6.4IMDb

Blockbuster man Gore Verbinski (The Ring) returns to horror in stately big budget haunter that’s a verifiable orgy of weird ideas. Ambitious to a fault, the story tells of a company man who goes to a spa to retrieve his fall-guy boss. Little healing occurs.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

OCULUS (2013)

🍅75%Critics🍿54%Audience⭐6.6IMDb

The mirror mirror on the wall has never been so imposing in this striking, intelligent, and emotionally rich horror-thriller about a haunted mirror. Credit Mike Flanagan and sturdy leads for making it all work.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review · Mike Flanagan Movies and Shows, Ranked

A QUIET PLACE: DAY ONE (2024)

🍅86%Critics🍿72%Audience⭐6.2IMDb

Essentially an art film about a dying woman’s quest for a final slice of NYC pizza, trojan-horsed into a genre flick, A Quiet Place: Day One boasts an excellent performance by Lupita Nyong’o (Joseph Quinn is also outstanding), helping keep this franchise fresh, relevant, and true to form.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

CLIMAX (2019)

🍅68%Critics🍿65%Audience⭐6.9IMDb

A band of French dancers start going crazy and killing each other when someone spikes the punch with acid in this hallucinogenic, kaleidoscopic whirlwind of sound and fury. Gaspar Noé shoots most of it in long, gliding takes set to a pounding ’90s dance soundtrack, and Sofia Boutella leads the descent.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

COHERENCE (2013)

🍅89%Critics🍿81%Audience⭐7.1IMDb

Stretching a heady sci-fi concept to razor-wire tautness, this eerie mindfuck also turned a nothing budget into a hazy intellectual exercise in minimalism and paranoia. Trust no-one, stay inside. Shot on a shoestring over a few nights with a largely improvised script, James Ward Byrkit’s dinner-party puzzle box rewards a second viewing.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video

BODIES BODIES BODIES (2022)

🍅85%Critics🍿69%Audience⭐6.1IMDb

Rich twenty-somethings play a party murder game during a hurricane blackout and someone actually dies. So many love triangles you’d need pins and yarn. Everyone’s as viable a suspect as in any tabletop game of Clue. Halina Reijn’s whodunit skewers group-chat paranoia, and Rachel Sennott steals every scene she’s in.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

SEW TORN (2024)

🍅95%Critics🍿68%Audience⭐6.0IMDb

A seamstress finds a suitcase of cash and two dying bikers on a Swiss roadside, and the film runs her three possible choices in full. Choose your own adventure where every road ends badly.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

THE DEEP HOUSE (2021)

🍅68%Critics🍿32%Audience⭐5.3IMDb

Two dive-vlogging influencers descend into a flooded French village and find an intact house at the bottom of the reservoir. A standard haunted house riff, but devil-worshipping ghouls floating at you underwater really resonated with my fear triggers.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video

HUSH (2016)

🍅92%Critics🍿73%Audience⭐6.6IMDb

The “She’s deaf” equivalent of A Quiet Place and Don’t Breathe, this unsettling invasion thriller (also from Flanagan) boils down the essential ingredients of a horror movie and delivers them in ideally measured fashion.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review · Mike Flanagan Movies and Shows, Ranked

PRIMATE (2026)

🍅77%Critics🍿69%Audience⭐5.8IMDb

Johannes Roberts’ brutal, and brutally effective, chimp gone bad horror joint Primate champions unrelenting tension and jaw-dropping gore, making this a January horror movie plenty worth infecting yourself with. Johannes Roberts traps a group of friends in a cliffside home with a rabid pet chimp, and the result is as lean and nasty as that premise suggests.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

TERRIFIER 2 (2022)

🍅88%Critics🍿81%Audience⭐6.0IMDb

Art the Clown is back, and his set pieces are longer, nastier, and more gleefully excessive than before. Damien Leone’s splatter epic is not for the faint of stomach, but for gorehounds it is an absolute event. David Howard Thornton’s silent, slapstick Art is the franchise’s secret weapon.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video

SYNCHRONIC (2020)

🍅79%Critics🍿76%Audience⭐6.2IMDb

A New Orleans paramedic with a terminal diagnosis works a run of impossible deaths caused by a designer drug that unsticks you in time.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

LAMB (2021)

🍅86%Critics🍿61%Audience⭐6.3IMDb

Icelandic sheep farmers deliver a lamb with a human body and raise it as the daughter they lost, until its mother comes to collect. Strange and singular, and I remain unconvinced it adds up to the menacing profundity intended.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

Want more? See the full ranking of the best horror movies of the 2020s.

TERRIFIER 3 (2024)

🍅78%Critics🍿85%Audience⭐6.2IMDb

Art the Clown does Christmas, which mostly means a Santa suit and a chainsaw in a shower. Little more than a “he’s back again” plot thatched onto grizzly kills, and almost certain to be a win for anyone who has followed him this far.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

SMILE 2 (2024)

🍅86%Critics🍿81%Audience⭐6.7IMDb

The grin-curse jumps to a pop star mid-comeback tour, where nobody can tell a breakdown from a haunting. Moving it onto a stage is smart; the mythology still develops in very similar ways.▶︎ Watch on Prime Video · Read the full review

BETTER WATCH OUT (2016)

🍅89%Critics🍿63%Audience⭐6.5IMDb

Santa will be adding some new names to the naughty list in this expectation-subverting Christmas bloodbath that coins the kill term “Home Alone-ing.” You’re curious now, aren’t you?▶︎ Watch on Prime Video

Critics and Audience scores from Rotten Tomatoes; ratings from IMDb. Scores as of November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

What’s the scariest movie on Prime Video right now?

If you want pure terror, start with Hereditary, followed by The Witch and Don’t Breathe. Hereditary remains the most traumatizing horror film of the last decade.

What are the best horror movies on Prime Video?

By my ranking, the best modern horror movies on Prime Video right now are Antlers (2021), The Witch (2015) and Pearl (2022).

How often is this list updated?

Every couple of weeks. I re-check Prime Video’s catalog regularly, adding new arrivals and removing anything that has left the service.

What are the best non-horror movies on Prime Video?

For my picks across every genre, see The Best Movies on Prime Video Right Now.

Some links on this page are affiliate links, so I may earn a small commission if you rent, buy, or sign up through them, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.